Explore galaxies.im

Myths versus facts

What this site will not say

A few claims that run ahead of the official record, and the official wording that replaces them.

  1. Myth. Planetary nebulae are places where planets form, or pictures of planets.

    Fact. Official pages say the name is historical. “Today these nebulae keep the name, but we know they have nothing to do with planets.” They form when low- to medium-mass stars expel their outer layers.

  2. Myth. The Helix Nebula is officially the “Eye of God.”

    Fact. Official wording says it “looks like a bubble or eye from Earth’s point of view,” and “is actually a trillion-mile-long tunnel of glowing gases.” This site does not treat the popular nickname as a fact.

  3. Myth. The black rectangle in the 1995 Pillars of Creation is a hole in the Eagle Nebula.

    Fact. It is the camera’s stairstep detector gap. The caption on this site says so.

  4. Myth. The dark shape in NGC 1999 is, as a current fact, a Bok globule.

    Fact. A 2000 Heritage caption used that identification. Later work found a hole in the cloud. This site describes NGC 1999 as a reflection nebula and does not repeat the older name as current fact.

  5. Myth. All nebulae glow with their own light.

    Fact. Emission nebulae do. Reflection nebulae shine by borrowed starlight. Absorption, or dark, nebulae block light from behind them.

  6. Myth. Dark nebulae are empty holes in space.

    Fact. They are clouds of gas and dust. Herschel called the seemingly empty spots “a hole in the sky,” but official pages describe dust that absorbs visible light.

  7. Myth. The Pleiades are shining on the leftover cloud they were born from.

    Fact. “Most nebulae around star clusters consist of material that the stars formed from. But the Pleiades shines on an independent cloud of gas and dust, drifting through the cluster at about 6.8 miles/second (11 km/s).”

  8. Myth. The Crab Nebula is a planetary nebula.

    Fact. Official pages present it as a supernova remnant, the wreck of an explosion in 1054, still expanding at around 3 million mph.

  9. Myth. A nebula is as dense as ordinary air.

    Fact. The interstellar medium can have “a density as low as 0.1 atoms per cubic centimeter,” beside “about 10 million trillion molecules” in a cubic centimetre of the air we breathe.

  10. Myth. Every official page agrees on one width for the Crab.

    Fact. The nebulae page gives a distance of 6,500 light-years and a speed of about 3 million mph. The official photograph caption describes a six-light-year-wide remnant. Both are kept, and attributed.

  11. Myth. “Unblinking eyes” is a formal official type of nebula.

    Fact. It is descriptive wording on the Hubble nebulae overview, alongside “twisting towers” and “floating bubbles,” not a type heading. The official type headings are emission, reflection, planetary, supernova remnants, and absorption.

  12. Myth. This site is an official NASA or ESA page.

    Fact. It is independent. NASA, ESA, STScI and NOAO names identify the records quoted.

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this nebula desk?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next galaxies.im site get built.